Writer’s note: I skipped all my classes today to write this lol
Today’s post will be a reflection on contentment:
Not that I am speaking of being in need, for I have learned in whatever situation I am to be content. I know how to be brought low, and I know how to abound. In any and every circumstance, I have learned the secret of facing plenty and hunger, abundance and need. I can do all things through him who strengthens me.
Philippians 4:11-13
Over the last few months, one area that God has been growing my heart in is contentment. Contentment is a funny topic that gets brought up whenever we’re told we can’t have something we want. The things I want, however, seems to make up a pretty long list (in no order of importance):
- I want for there to be no more war between Russia and Ukraine and for justice to be accomplished, that the right people would be brought down and held accountable for their actions
- I want my all small group members to show up every week attentive with a heart to grow and a desire for evangelism and discipleship
- I want my church community to be more tight-knit, for us to push each other closer to God, and for there to be a communal desire to make His name known
- I want to see my family and friends recognise the goodness of God and have their lives transformed, and I wish it were easier both to share with them, and to have them listen
- I want to be married one day to someone who will push me to faithfully and deeply pursue Christ, who can cover my blind spots, and who I can share my life with
- I want to have clarity on where and how I should spend my life serving God and not have to make so many decisions about what my next steps should be profession-wise
- I want to stop facing conflicts and difficult situations, and wish I would never have to see the people I care about being hurt by circumstances beyond my control
- I want to be able to keep in touch with the people that are important to me forever and never have to worry about changing relationships or being alone
- I want to be rich so I don’t have to worry about finances and can spend freely while being able to support and bless others in ways I may not be able to otherwise
This is not a comprehensive list. It’s only a small look into what I want but cannot have (some for now, others maybe never as long as I am on this earth). I have to be honest about this as well: I’m a complainer. I grumble and I groan and there’s always something I’m displeased about. And I think it’s for that very reason contentment has been such an important topic of meditation for me lately. It’s an area that God has been humbling and training me in.
Let’s be real as well: I’m tired of being humbled. So I’ve been taking it into my own hands to grow in contentment. I’ve started practicing fasting (from food), I’ve decided to pursue a season of singleness (intentionally this time), and I’ve gone off most social media (probably for the next while). Here are some lessons that I’ve learned along the way:
- What contentment DOES NOT mean:
- We are in love with our situation
- We are in a state of complaining and groaning (Phil 2:14)
- We no longer have desires
When I hear others talk about contentment, an impression that I often get is that it must be going swell. Not necessarily that their circumstances are swell but that everything must be swell in their hearts and their emotions. The impression is that they’re simply OK with suffering and hardship and have simply suppressed their desires in a way that they no longer ‘want’ anything. The area that this seems to come up most often is regarding (dating) relationships.
Whenever the topic of contentment has come up in this area, I’ve always imagined it in a way where it meant you no longer desired a relationship. But pairing that with the (annoying and not always helpful) stories of people saying “I met this person when I learned to be content with singleness,” contentment made no sense to me. How does absolving your desires for something help you gain that very thing? And if you have no desire for that thing anymore, why would you even want to be in such a position? As you can see, confusion all around.
I think the first thing that needs to be addressed is that not all desires are bad. God, in all his glory, made the world and said “it was good” (Gen 1:31). There are many good things and many things that are honourable for us to desire. In Proverbs, the very notion of finding a wife is described as a ‘good thing’ (Proverbs 18:22 ESV). Okay, so relationships aren’t bad to desire but what does it mean to be content? In Sam Allberry’s 7 Myths About Singleness, he spends six chapters defending singleness, saying that like marriage, it has both its own challenges and blessings and that we should not take either for granted. In the seventh and final chapter, he shares his own experience with singleness and lays it on us: it’s hard. He shares about the family he can never have, battles with loneliness, and the pain of always being second on everyone else’s priority list. He humbly recognises what he wants yet cannot have, but still wrestles with the pain of it–is that contentment?
Another thing that needs to emphasised is that contentment is NOT being in a state of complaining and grumbling. In the very two chapters prior (Phil 2:14), Paul addresses this–he tells us to “do all things without grumbling or disputing.” There is no way we can be in a state of contentment if we continually and openly express contempt for the situation we’re in while acting ungrateful for the things that God has provided us. It is one thing to be unhappy with the situation we’re in. It is another to allow it to affect our actions and the way that we treat God and others.
For my final point, it is from the hunger of fasting that I’ve learned the most important item on this list: contentment is NOT having no more desires. When you fast, you face the feeling of hunger. It’s inevitable. Your body needs food for energy and you need it to stay alive. That feeling of hunger comes with a desire to eat food. What does it look like to be content while being hungry? If our definition of contentment is to no longer desire to eat, then that’s impossible! Being hungry and desiring to eat is not something that we have control of, it is the natural response of our bodies that God has created us with. God has given us the desire to eat so that we may stay alive. In this case, contentment is not giving up the desire for food but giving up the “right”, “expectation”, and “privilege” to eat. I think this principle applies to many other scenarios as well. If we bring it back to the topic of relationships, contentment is not giving up the desire to have a relationship but giving up the expectation that you will have one. Now the next question is: what should it look like to want something but be okay with not having it?
2. What contentment DOES mean:
- We set realistic and reasonable expectations
- We trust and worship God regardless of circumstance
- We set our eyes and hearts on the things above
Along with figuring out what contentment does not mean, I think that I’ve come to a better idea of what contentment does mean. And above are the three things that I’ve decided on.
The first thing that contentment requires us to do is to set realistic and reasonable expectations. Now, you might be thinking, “shouldn’t the first step be to trust and worship God regardless of circumstance?” Well, I think they go hand-in-hand, and setting those realistic expectations is what allows us to trust God, and vice-versa. If we are trusting God to fulfill all our wants in the exact way and time that we want them, then we are trusting in a delusion. Not only will that never happen and leave us disappointed, it will make us angry and frustrated at God. There’s two components of this setting expectations. The first component is knowing what God has promised us. This requires us to search his word and know his character. If God has promised something, like making sure our needs are met (Matthew 6:25-34), then it is a realistic expectation we can set. The second component is learning to give up expectations in our day-to-day lives of what God has not promised. Although finding a wife, and wanting no more war, and desiring your loved ones to know God as you do, are good desires, He has made no such promise to fulfill these wants. We can want them and desire them and yearn for them and pray for them, but we must be careful not to expect them in our way and in our time and for our reasons, otherwise we will never be content.
It is by knowing God and his promises that we can worship, trust, and obey him “in every circumstance”, as Paul says. If we are aware of the promises he has made, we can live contently knowing that God has our greater good in mind even if it doesn’t play out in the ways and at the time and for the reasons we want. For example, let us go back to the passage in Matthew 6:25-34. In these verses, God promises that he will always provide for our necessities as long as we seek his kingdom and righteousness first. There are two things we can take away from this passage. The first is that we can set this expectation for ourselves based on God’s promises, and trust him to provide for us without risk of disappointment. The second, then, is that by knowing this, we can worship and obey Him in that trust. Contentment is not a quiet bitterness in not getting what we want, but rather a joyful gratitude in the promises and gifts that God has given us.
Although contentment is not about having no more desires, another way it can be realized is by re-directing our desires. Once again, this comes from knowing God and His promises. In the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus warns us about where we store our treasures:
Do not store up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moths and vermin destroy, and where thieves break in and steal. But store up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where moths and vermin do not destroy, and where thieves do not break in and steal. For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also.
Matthew 6:19-21
There are two things we are to learn from this passage. The first is that our treasures on earth are temporary. Not only do they have an expiry date (Luke 12:13-21) but there are “moths and vermin” who will destroy and thieves who will “break in and steal.” The second is that not only do earthly treasures pass away, there are actually better treasures we can attain. There are treasures in heaven that are resistant to the moths and vermin and thieves in the world. And on top of that, these treasures are also eternal. They have no expiry date because they are not part of a world that is passing away (1 John 2:17). What that means for us is that we should re-direct and prioritize our hearts and desires to these better treasures. That doesn’t necessarily mean we will have no more desires for earthly things (as discussed in the first section), but rather that we should make a conscious effort to strive for what is better, and use our desires for earthly goods to actually work towards fulfilling our eternal desires (i.e., instead of desiring food for its own sake, we desire food so that it might nourish our bodies so that we can use our bodies to work towards eternal goods, or so that we can have food to share with others and thus display a love that will achieve for us eternal rewards). If you think sliced bread, air conditioning, and Wi-Fi are great, imagine how much greater the creator of all those things is, and his promises of eternal goods that far surpass all of them!
3. Implications for contentment:
- Contentment is an attitude that requires being intentional
- We can want and be content
- We can grieve and be content
Now that I have discussed what contentment means and what contentment does not mean, I can move onto some implications of contentment that were not so obvious to me at first.
The first thing is that contentment is an attitude that requires being intentional. We can’t control all our circumstances, nor our desires, nor our ability to obtain all our desires, but what we can learn to control is our attitude. Contentment is something that requires us to be mindful of whether or not we grumble, whether or not we have realistic expectations, and whether or not we worship God. These are things we must evaluate especially in seasons where God or others are telling us we cannot have something we want. Am I complaining bitterly or am I practicing joyful gratitude in what God has provided? Am I setting realistic expectations based on the promises that God has given me or am I getting ahead of myself? Am I continuing to worship and obey God in all circumstances or am I doing it selectively? These are things in our control.
The second is slightly reiterated from the first section, but I believe it is worth repeating. It is that we can want and still be content. Being content doesn’t mean we will have no more desires. What it does mean is that we are aware that some of those desires may never be realized in the way or time we want them to or think they should be, and we thus have to set expectations accordingly. Think of Paul’s desire to have the “thorn” removed from his side. But Christ, ever faithful, promised a grace that would be sufficient for all the desires Paul might have.
The last thing I want to mention is that we can grieve and be content (you just have to read the Psalms or the account of Job or the lives of the Prophets to see this). If being content means we are still allowed to have wants then it must also mean that we are allowed to grieve over those wants not being fulfilled. We can set realistic expectations for what we think God will fulfill but still be disappointed in the ones he does not fulfill.
Going back to that list of wants I stated at the beginning of this post, I’m not sure how many of them will ever be fulfilled. Most of them probably won’t ever be, and that doesn’t mean I have to be happy about it. But being sad about them also doesn’t mean I have to grumble. It doesn’t mean I have to be bitter at God. It doesn’t mean God didn’t hold up his end of the bargain. It doesn’t mean I can’t worship and obey him. And it doesn’t mean that I have no desire for better treasures. What it does mean is that while God has given me desires, not all of them will be fulfilled how and when and why I want. That’s the reality, and regardless of it, I’ll be OK because I can trust God has what’s best in mind for me (Romans 8:28).
Stay cool,
Jason